In the 1990s, Spring Valley's Haitian community is rocked when a well-respected civic leader is murdered. It takes police nearly two decades to sift through the rumours and solve a mystery filled with lies and dark secrets.

The quiet suburb of Haddon Township, N.J., is turned upside down when a toddler goes missing. Residents band together to search local streets and parks, and help detectives reveal an unlikely murderer living in their close-knit community.

Folks in Anchorage, Alaska are shaken to their core when a popular barista goes missing.

In 1982, Alice McArthur, the wife of Bill, a prominent criminal defense attorney, is killed by two men delivering flowers.

Nashville performer and "Hee Haw" star David "Stringbean" Akeman had a strange habit. The banjo picker and joke teller kept $3,000 in cash in his overall's bib pocket, and ten times that hidden at home--cash for a rainy day. For Akeman and his wife, that rainy day never came. Murdered in 1973, their killers never found either stash.

The military community at Fort Meade is shocked when a soldier is shot to death in her townhome. For nearly a year, investigators from multiple law enforcement agencies work tirelessly to uncover a twisted tale of secrets and lies that led to murder.

When a lobsterman discovers the ankle of a partially decomposed body in his trap, a local "witch" helps solve the crime.

A quiet community is rocked when one of their own is found brutally murdered; police struggle.

A popular lifeguard is found dead at the community swimming pool

The shocking murders of attorney Vince Sherry and his politically-active wife Margaret make the already-hot summer of 1987 sizzle in Biloxi, Mississippi.