What are the best episodes of Mystery Files?

The best rated episodes of Mystery Files are: The Aliens That Terrorized A Kentucky Family In 1955 - S3E1 rated 9.0, The Freaky Case of Gef the Talking Mongoose - S3E2 rated 8.5, The Largest Unexplained Explosion in History - S1E2 rated 8.5, The Horrifying Killings of El Chupacabra - S1E3 rated 8.3, Is Spontaneous Human Combustion Actually Real? - S4E1 rated 8.0, The Grisly Crimes of the Czinkota Vampire - S3E4 rated 8.0, Uncovering the Alien Encounters of the US Government - S2E7 rated 8.0, The Sinister Letters That Terrorized A Small Town - S2E1 rated 8.0

What are the worst episodes of Mystery Files?

The lowest rated episodes of Mystery Files are: The Disturbing Disappearance of the Princes in the Tower - S4E4 rated 5.0, The Outrageous Plot to Steal The Millennium Star Diamond - S4E6 rated 6.0, The Unhinged Bank Heist of D.B. Tuber - S1E1 rated 6.9, The Perplexing Legend of Vermont's Sea Monster - S2E2 rated 7.0, The Deranged Arsonist Who Filmed Their Own Crime - S2E3 rated 7.0, The World’s Most Mysterious Book That No One Can Decode - S2E4 rated 7.0, The Toxic Blobs That Rained Down On Washington - S2E5 rated 7.0, The Phantom Air Raid That Plunged Los Angeles into Darkness - S2E6 rated 7.0

Mystery Files Episode Rating Graph

May 2023 - present

7.1

Mystery Files Episode Rating Graph poster

Mystery Files Episode Rating Chart

Terrible

	E1	E2	E3	E4	E5	E6	E7	E8
S1
S2
S3
S4

Browse episode ratings trends for Mystery Files. Simply click on the interactive rating graph to explore the best and worst of Mystery Files's 26 episodes.

Best Episodes of Mystery Files

The Aliens That Terrorized A Kentucky Family In 1955
S3 Ep1
9.0
21st Mar 2025
Ryan dives into the bizarre extraterrestrial attack on a farmhouse in a small Kentucky town.
The Freaky Case of Gef the Talking Mongoose
S3 Ep2
8.5
28th Mar 2025
Shane tells the tale of Gef, the witty and slightly threatening talking mongoose who lived with the Irving family on the Isle of Man.
The Largest Unexplained Explosion in History
S1 Ep2
8.5
26th May 2023
Shane explores Russia's strange Tunguska Event, Earth's largest recorded impact event. Sensitive Topics: Natural disasters, injuries
The Horrifying Killings of El Chupacabra
S1 Ep3
8.3
2nd Jun 2023
Sensitive topics: deceased animals, mutilation. Ryan deep dives into one of the world's favorite cryptids, the notorious Chupacabra.
Is Spontaneous Human Combustion Actually Real?
S4 Ep1
8.0
1st Aug 2025
Mystery Files is back and the boys get to play with fire! Don't worry, the set is still intact.
The Grisly Crimes of the Czinkota Vampire
S3 Ep4
8.0
11th Apr 2025
Shane tells Ryan about Hungarian serial killer Béla Kiss and the disturbing crimes that took place in Czinkota.
Uncovering the Alien Encounters of the US Government
S2 Ep7
8.0
5th Apr 2024
Ryan explores the US Government's suspected involvement in aliens and UFO sightings in America. Sensitive topics: N/A
The Sinister Letters That Terrorized A Small Town
S2 Ep1
8.0
23rd Feb 2024
Ryan delves into the Circleville Letters, the bizarre, threatening letters that endlessly plagued a small town. Sensitive Topics: Stalking, Mention of Violence, Suicide, DUI, Murder.

Worst Episodes of Mystery Files

The Disturbing Disappearance of the Princes in the Tower
S4 Ep4
5.0
22nd Aug 2025
A murderous plot? A daring escape? A horrifying haunting? Grab a snack and help us unpack...wait, that's the wrong show. Strap in and stay alive as Shane recounts the tragic tale of two princes!
The Outrageous Plot to Steal The Millennium Star Diamond
S4 Ep6
6.0
5th Sep 2025
We embark on our most daring Mystery Files stunt yet while covering the infamous Millennium Star Diamond heist!
The Unhinged Bank Heist of D.B. Tuber
S1 Ep1
6.9
19th May 2023
Ryan presents Shane with the wild tale of the D.B. Tuber bank heist. Sensitive Topics: Illegal activities, assault, drug use
The Perplexing Legend of Vermont's Sea Monster
S2 Ep2
7.0
1st Mar 2024
Shane explores the myth of Champ, the Nessie-like sea creature that supposedly lives in Lake Champlaign. Sensitive Topics: Cryptids
The Deranged Arsonist Who Filmed Their Own Crime
S2 Ep3
7.0
8th Mar 2024
Ryan tells Shane about the Stockton Arsonist, the mysterious pyromaniac who filmed his own crime. Sensitive Topics: Arson, Satanism, a brief mention of violence towards animals
The World’s Most Mysterious Book That No One Can Decode
S2 Ep4
7.0
15th Mar 2024
Shane goes on a deep dive into the Voynich Manuscript, the old book full of unexplained text and strange drawings that has a fanbase of its own. Sensitive Topics: N/A
The Toxic Blobs That Rained Down On Washington
S2 Ep5
7.0
22nd Mar 2024
Ryan explores the incident of the Oakville Blobs, the strange goo that rained over Oakville, Washington and got residents and animals sick. Sensitive Topics: Animal death, illnesses, potential trypophobia
The Phantom Air Raid That Plunged Los Angeles into Darkness
S2 Ep6
7.0
29th Mar 2024
Shane tells Ryan about the Battle of Los Angeles, the bizarre air raid that took place in California during WWII and definitely NOT the movie. Sensitive topics: Descriptions of bodily injuries

Mystery Files Episode Guide

The Unhinged Bank Heist of D.B. Tuber
S1 Ep1
6.9
19th May 2023
Ryan presents Shane with the wild tale of the D.B. Tuber bank heist. Sensitive Topics: Illegal activities, assault, drug use
The Largest Unexplained Explosion in History
S1 Ep2
8.5
26th May 2023
Shane explores Russia's strange Tunguska Event, Earth's largest recorded impact event. Sensitive Topics: Natural disasters, injuries
The Horrifying Killings of El Chupacabra
S1 Ep3
8.3
2nd Jun 2023
Sensitive topics: deceased animals, mutilation. Ryan deep dives into one of the world's favorite cryptids, the notorious Chupacabra.
The Strange Disappearance of The Leatherman
S1 Ep4
8.0
9th Jun 2023
Shane investigates the legend of the lonely vagabond, The Leatherman, and the mysterious circumstances of his death. Sensitive topics: physical distress, death
The Apocalyptic Sounds Heard Around The World
S1 Ep5
7.7
16th Jun 2023
Ryan explores the strange noises that blared through the sky, christened as "The Sky Trumpets", and the possible explanations for their existence. Sensitive topics: physical/mental distress, aliens
The Maniacal TV Hijacking of Max Headroom
S1 Ep6
8.0
23rd Jun 2023
Shane explores the disturbing Chicago news hijacking of "Max Headroom" and the feelings of fear that followed. Sensitive topics: static noises, mildly obscene activity (spanking)

The best rated episodes of Mystery Files are:

The Aliens That Terrorized A Kentucky Family In 1955 S3E1 rated 9.0
The Freaky Case of Gef the Talking Mongoose S3E2 rated 8.5
The Largest Unexplained Explosion in History S1E2 rated 8.5
The Horrifying Killings of El Chupacabra S1E3 rated 8.3
Is Spontaneous Human Combustion Actually Real? S4E1 rated 8.0
The Grisly Crimes of the Czinkota Vampire S3E4 rated 8.0
Uncovering the Alien Encounters of the US Government S2E7 rated 8.0
The Sinister Letters That Terrorized A Small Town S2E1 rated 8.0

The lowest rated episodes of Mystery Files are:

The Disturbing Disappearance of the Princes in the Tower S4E4 rated 5.0
The Outrageous Plot to Steal The Millennium Star Diamond S4E6 rated 6.0
The Unhinged Bank Heist of D.B. Tuber S1E1 rated 6.9
The Perplexing Legend of Vermont's Sea Monster S2E2 rated 7.0
The Deranged Arsonist Who Filmed Their Own Crime S2E3 rated 7.0
The World’s Most Mysterious Book That No One Can Decode S2E4 rated 7.0
The Toxic Blobs That Rained Down On Washington S2E5 rated 7.0
The Phantom Air Raid That Plunged Los Angeles into Darkness S2E6 rated 7.0