An indigenous woman kidnapped by a conquistador returns to her homeland with the help of her Spanish lover, but a turn of events destroys her trust in him.

Pedro frees Catalina and the two escape, but not without serious injury. As pedro nurses Catalina, a bond develops between them.

When the mine's owner comes to visit, Pedro takes a risk and proposes an idea that could benefit everyone. Nicuesa puts the convent under surveillance.

When the governor orders Catalina's return to Nicuesa, Father Bartolomé and Catalina appear before the goverment official to plead their case.

When Pedro returns and find Mencía beaten, he attacks Linares. But in the ensuing scuffle, Fernando is accidentally shot, and Pedro must save him.

Beatriz offers Andrés intel. in exchange for her passage on a ship. Nicuesa's men abduct Enriquillo and hold him for a ransom: Catalina.

Pedro helps Catalina escape from the ship, but once on land again, he's captured by Andrés, who believes it was Pedro who led the slave rebellion.

With help from Mencía, Beatriz, and Father Bartolomé, Pedro is rescued from his executioners and stowed away on a ship with Catalina.

Badillo agrees to help Catalina find her tribe, but wants her help in return. Meanwhile, Pedro returns to Spain to save his brother from execution.

To save Alberto's life, Pedro orders Alonso to offer Azula a deal. Badillo's wife manipulates Catalina into going on a fool's errand.